Marginal value is a misnomer. Market prices reveal the median value.

Ever since the Marginal Revolution of the late 19th century, economics has been defined by marginal benefit and marginal cost. That is what determines the most famous picture in economics, the supply and demand graph.  The demand curve is really the marginal benefit curve (measured in mmutility) and the supply curve is really the marginal cost curve.  The equilibrium market price is where the marginal cost (as estimated by sellers) is the same price as the marginal benefit (as estimated by buyers).  All buyers value the good at the market price or higher and all other sellers value the good at the market price or lower.  This means that the market price is the median valuation among market participants.  If you lined up the valuation of each market participant for each good from lowest to highest, the market price is right at the median valuation.  That point also happens to separate the valuations of the sellers from that of the buyers.

In effect, a market is a like a voting mechanism where people vote with dollars to determine the median valuation.  The main difference from democracy is that people with more resources get more votes in markets. It is the median valuation of the participants that determines the market price. For this reason, it was misleading for Noah Smith to say that:

nearly everyone on Wall Street was eager to tell you back in 2012 that QE would cause a big rise in inflation. But when you looked at TIPS spreads, it was clear that the marginal investor wasn’t putting his money where his mouth was.

Noah Smith appears to be saying that only a “marginal investor” was betting against inflation.  What he really meant to say is MUCH stronger.  He meant to say that the median investor dollar was betting against inflation.  You can easily search Google News for 2012 and see that Wall Street tycoons and media outlets were predicting (again) that the third round of quantitative easing would cause big inflation.  Meanwhile the median investor dollar was generally expecting slightly lower inflation than before.  Investors who feared inflation could buy inflation-protected government bonds (called TIPS), but the interest-rate spread between TIPS and regular bonds did not rise.  TIPS pay their interest rate plus the inflation rate whereas regular bonds just pay their interest rate so the spread between TIPS and regular bonds is the median bond market prediction of future inflation.

Below is a FRED graph showing how the median investor did not predict higher inflation during any of the three periods of the most massive quantitative easing in US history (when the red line jumped).  The monetary base is now five times larger than it was from 2005-2008 and since quantitative easing began the bond market has been showing lower 10-year inflation expectations than it did before quantitative easing started.

inflation tips spread QE

Noah Smith meant that when a market price changes a little bit, it only necessarily means that a few of the people with valuations near the median have changed their minds about the price.  All we can say about all the other valuations is that half are higher and half are lower.  But when economists talk about “marginal investors”, ordinary people are going to think about the ordinary English definition of “marginal” and think that that means “fringe investors” are betting on low inflation. In reality Noah Smith meant that the median investor dollar was betting that inflation would not rise.  A better way to say it is that a majority of investor bets were predicting low inflation.  That sounds very different than what Noah Smith wrote.

Posted in Macro, Medianism

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 96 other subscribers
Blog Archive