What is imputed rent?

Suppose you own a house worth $240,000, but your job forces you to move to Chicago for two years where you will have to pay $12,000 ($1,000/month) to rent another house with nearly identical characteristics. Fortunately, you can rent out your house for $12,000, but this won’t completely cover your cost of housing because you will have to pay 25% income tax on the rent you earn ($3,000), so your gross housing bill goes up just because you are paying rent for the same kind of housing. As it turns out, your new landlord is Jane who happens to also be relocating to your town and she will be renting your house and paying you $12,000 too. Legally, she will also have to pay $3,000 income tax on the rent you are paying her, but if you can both just quietly agree to trade houses without any money being exchanged, you can both avoid paying these taxes. 

That is imputed rent and everyone who owns their home is getting the same kind of economic benefit stream (a.k.a. income) from owning their home whether they rent out the home or whether they live in it. If they rent it out, they get rent payments, and if they live in it themselves, then they are earning “imputed rent”. Imputed rent is the rental value that an owner would get from renting the home they occupy at market rates. A few countries including Iceland, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Slovenia, and Switzerland do tax imputed rent, and where it is not taxed (like in the US) it is the biggest subsidy for home ownership. For example, suppose you were renting for $12,000 ($1,000/month), and earning $1,000/month on $240,000 in savings. If you used your savings to buy the house where you live for $240,000, you would still be getting the same amount of earnings from your savings ($1,000/month), but your taxes would drop under the American system which ignores imputed rent. It isn’t fair to levy a higher tax on people who have invested their savings in stocks or bonds rather than in housing.

In addition, there are a lot more tax breaks for homeowners like the mortgage-interest tax break that increase the government tax subsidies for home ownership. The mortgage-interest tax break would make sense in the above nations where imputed rent is taxed because in that case the interest would be just like any other business expense, but in the US, it is just an extra subsidy on top of the savings from avoiding taxes on imputed rent income.

Below is a graph from the Urban Institute via VOX that shows how much the OTHER kinds of subsidies benefit owner-occupied households in different income classes, but with interest rates so low right now, the tax savings of untaxed imputed rent is probably much bigger than the more explicit subsidies shown in the graph below, at least for families in high income tax brackets.

The rent that home owners pay themselves is a kind of tax-free income and combined with the other subsidies for homeowners, renting becomes a worse deal financially than buying for most Americans who are going to live in one place long enough to cover the higher transactions costs of buying a home.  

These subsidies are wasteful because they decrease labor mobility (because homeowners have higher transactions costs that impede them from moving closer to new jobs) and they encourage Americans to spend excessive amounts on mcmansions.  These policies are also regressive because most people below the median income don’t get the subsidies because they rent whereas most Americans above the median do get them because home ownership rates rise with income and the subsides are higher for more expensive homes and even the plutocrats with numerous homes get the imputed rent subsidy for owning them.      

Posted in Public Finance

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 49 other followers

Blog Archive